Bad Science?
5 Feb

Three weeks ago I was feeling a little bit… January. I might just have plucked the name of that condition from nowhere, but the symptoms are decidedly recognisable: sluggishness, lack of energy, dull skin and a near-constant desire to huddle under the nearest duvet and watch Judy Garland films in the middle of the day.
Unfortunately, my current schedule does not permit daytime sofa nesting (more’s the pity, right?). So in a bid to combat my start of year lack of lustre, I began to do two other things instead: the first was to start swallowing a multi-vitamin tablet everyday, and the second was to take up drinking pro-biotic yoghurt.
Now let me be clear on this. I don’t generally buy into health fads. Besides the weighty streak of good old-fashioned Scottish scepticism that pulses through my veins, I read Bad Science a couple of years ago and drew my own conclusions about the “healthy living” industry, many of which were firmly rooted in cynicism. I’m also wary of buying anything health-related that’s advertised on a “purchase and feel amazing” basis. The packaging is always a dead give away with these things. If it features a lithe, tanned model with disturbingly white teeth doing some kind of fist-pumping “I FEEL AWESOME” victory dance, I’m usually walking away. Let’s not even think about the perma-tanned, disturbingly white-toothed family, where the kids look creepily similar in age to the parents and they’re all facing the camera with glued-on smiles and glassy eyes.
Having said that, I’m not against giving things a go. Someone told me recently that the Finnish Government actually recommends that its citizens take Vitamin D supplements in Winter to combat the adverse effects of there being so little sun around. And I also recently read somewhere that taking pro-biotics can help to strengthen your intestinal wall, meaning that toxins and other bad stuff finds it harder to get into your blood stream where it can wreak havoc with your skin. Worth trying, at least.
Furthermore, and this is actually something I do happen to believe in, there’s the placebo effect. I may be a cynic when it comes to some things, but if an act as simple and as ostensibly harmless as popping a multi-vitamin every morning helps me to believe I’m feeling better, then what does it matter if in actual fact it’s having no effect on my physical health whatsoever? Multivitamins cost a fraction of a pence each, they don’t taste offensive and as far as I’ve read there are no adverse effects to result from taking them. Ditto pro-biotics, which admittedly are a lot more expensive (but which taste delicious!). So my question is this: if it’s not actively bad for me, who the hell cares that the benefits might only exist in my head?
It goes without saying that it’s nigh on impossible to tell what the real effects of pro-biotics or vitamin supplements are. And a simple Google search for ‘Vitamin D’ quickly reveals that the internet is no place to find a straightforward solution. Everyone and his best mate seems to be on his soap box on some health forum somewhere, and the number of people singing the praises seems pretty well balanced against the number of people scaremongering about conspiracies, corruption and corporate greed.
I suppose in the end it all comes down to how you or I as individuals feel about these things. I have felt better since I started popping pills and drinking bacteria. I feel less bloated after meals, which could be because the yoghurts are helping out with the business of digestion. My skin is smoother and brighter, which could be because all that vitamin D is taking its toll. Or it could just be that I’m feeling good because it’s finally not January any more. The flipping of a page on the calendar perhaps has a greater effect on me than I’m aware of.
The bottom line is, I don’t know. I don’t think anyone does. As long as I feel OK, however, I’m not really sure that it matters.
What’s your take on vitamin supplements? Pro-biotic drinks? Pro? Anti? Indifferent?
Image above from here.





